US Supreme Court rejects Trump bid to block Capitol attack document release

By AFP   January 19, 2022 | 07:30 pm PT
US Supreme Court rejects Trump bid to block Capitol attack document release
The US Supreme Court rejected a bid by former president Donald Trump to block the release of documents to a congressional committee investigating the January 6 attack on the Capitol. Photo by AFP/Samuel Corum
The US Supreme Court on Wednesday rejected a bid by former president Donald Trump to block the release to a congressional committee of documents related to the January 6 attack on the Capitol.

Citing executive privilege, Trump had sought to prevent the records held by the National Archives from being given to the panel investigating the assault on Congress by his supporters.

Trump, who has been accused of fomenting the Capitol assault, had asked the nation's highest court to stay a ruling by a federal appeals court, which rejected his efforts to keep the documents secret.

But the Supreme Court, in an 8-1 vote, refused to issue a stay and upheld the lower court's ruling, in a significant setback for the former president.

Justice Clarence Thomas, a conservative, was the only justice in favor of issuing a stay.

The other five conservative justices on the court -- three of whom were appointed by Trump -- joined the three liberals in denying the request.

The leaders of the House Select Committee investigating the January 6 attack, Democratic Chairman Bennie Thompson and Republican Vice Chair Liz Cheney, applauded the decision.

"The Supreme Court’s action tonight is a victory for the rule of law and American democracy," they said in a statement. "Our work goes forward to uncover all the facts about the violence of January 6th and its causes."

Trump had sought to exercise his privilege as a former president to keep under wraps White House records and communications that might relate to the attack.

In a filing with the Supreme Court, Trump's lawyers had argued that "a former president has the right to assert executive privilege, even after his term of office."

They condemned the congressional records request as "strikingly broad" and accused the committee in the Democratic-controlled House of Representatives of conducting a probe of a "political foe."

President Joe Biden waived executive privilege on the Trump records so they could be handed over to the committee and the appeals court decided that "the right of a former president certainly enjoys no greater weight than that of the incumbent."

The appeals court said the public interest was greater than Trump's own in relation to the records.

"In this case, President Biden, as the head of the Executive Branch, has specifically found that Congress has demonstrated a compelling need for these very documents and that disclosure is in the best interests of the nation," the court said.

Emails, phone records

The House Select Committee is scrutinizing the January 6 attempt by hundreds of Trump supporters to block congressional certification of Biden's November 2020 election victory.

Documents that Trump hoped to block include emails, phone records, briefing materials and other records.

The more than 770 pages include records of his former chief of staff Mark Meadows, his former senior advisor Stephen Miller and his former deputy counsel Patrick Philbin.

Trump had also sought to block the release of the White House Daily Diary -- a record of his activities, trips, briefings and phone calls.

Another trove of documents Trump does not want Congress to see includes memos to his former press secretary Kayleigh McEnany, a handwritten note on the January 6 events and a draft text of his speech at the "Save America" rally, which preceded the attack.

The congressional committee is looking into how the attack, which shut down the Congress, took place, and whether Trump and members of his circle had any part in encouraging it.

It has already issued subpoenas for several key figures in Trump's orbit, including Meadows and one-time White House strategist Steve Bannon.

On Tuesday, the committee issued subpoenas to former New York mayor Rudy Giuliani -- a key figure in Trump's failed bid to overturn the 2020 election -- and three other allies of the defeated ex-president.

go to top