South China Sea ruling will 'intensify conflict': Chinese envoy

By Reuters/David Brunnstrom, Ben Blanchard   July 12, 2016 | 05:11 pm PT
South China Sea ruling will 'intensify conflict': Chinese envoy
Protesters throw flowers while chanting anti-Chinese slogans during a rally by different activist groups over the South China Sea disputes, along a bay in metro Manila, Philippines July 12, 2016. Photo bt Reuters/Romeo Ranoco
And Hillary Clinton welcomes South China Sea ruling, says it is critical to U.S. economy.

An international tribunal's ruling denying China's claims in the South China Sea (Vietnam's East Sea) will "intensify conflict and even confrontation," Beijing's ambassador to the United States said on Tuesday.

The ambassador, Cui Tiankai, also told an international forum in Washington that Beijing remains committed to negotiations with other parties in disputes over the vital trade route.

In a case that was seen as a test of China's rising power and its economic and strategic rivalry with the United States, the Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague ruled China had breached the Philippines' sovereign rights by endangering its ships and fishing and oil projects in the energy-rich region.

The Chinese diplomat blamed the rise in tension in the region on the United States' "pivot" toward Asia in the past few years. Cui said the arbitration case "will probably open the door of abusing arbitration procedures.

"It will certainly undermine and weaken the motivation of states to engage in negotiations and consultations for solving their disputes," Cui said. "It will certainly intensify conflict and even confrontation."

China boycotted the arbitration hearings and described them as a farce. Legal experts and Asia policy specialists said China risked violating international law if it continued to strike a defiant tone and ignored the ruling.

The United States, which China has accused of fuelling tensions and militarising the region with patrols and exercises, said the ruling should be treated as final and binding.

"We certainly would urge all parties not to use this as an opportunity to engage in escalatory or provocative action," White House spokesman Josh Earnest told reporters in a briefing.

The ruling is significant as it is the first time that a legal challenge has been brought in the dispute. The court has no power of enforcement, but a victory for the Philippines could spur Taiwan, Vietnam, Malaysia and Brunei to file similar cases on their claims to the waters.

China's Foreign Ministry rejected the tribunal's ruling, saying its people had more than 2,000 years of history in the South China Sea, that its islands did have exclusive economic zones and that it had announced to the world its "dotted line" map in 1948.

Ambassador Cui told the CSIS forum that China "will do everything possible to safeguard the unimpeded flow of commerce and stop any attempt to destabilize the region."


Security personell guard the area near the Philippine embassy in Beijing, July 12, 2016. Photo by Reuters/Thomas Peter


The Philippines said it was studying the ruling.

"We call on all those concerned to exercise restraint and sobriety," Foreign Affairs Secretary Perfecto Yasay told a news conference.

U.S. State Department spokesman John Kirby said Washington has seen signs in recent weeks of continued militarization by China in the South China Sea.

President Barack Obama's top Asia policy adviser, Daniel Kritenbrink, said the United States had no interest in stirring tensions in the South China Sea as a pretext for involvement in the region.

"We have an enduring interest in seeing territorial and maritime disputes in the Asia Pacific, including in the South China Sea, resolved peacefully, without coercion and in a manner that is consistent with international law," Kritenbrink said at a forum of the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS).

U.S. ally Australia warned against "unilateral actions" by any claimants.

"Australia will continue to exercise our international law rights to freedom of navigation and overflight, and support the right of others to do so," Foreign Minister Julie Bishop said in a statement.

International law experts described the ruling as a legal blow to Beijing's claims in the disputed waters and one that brought the United States, China and Southeast Asia to a dangerous crossroads.

"This is a tactical victory for the Philippines and a strategic defeat for international law," said Chas Freeman, a former U.S. diplomat who was then-President Richard Nixon's interpreter on his historic trip to China in 1972.

"This decision has left the issue in the condition where it can only be resolved by the use of force. There is no diplomatic process underway to settle claims, and now there's no longer a legal process," Freeman said.

Julia Guifang Xue, a professor of international law at Shanghai Jiao Tong University said that given Beijing's sensitivity about sovereignty and security "we won't be surprised to see some kind of renewed effort by China to consolidate its claim in the area."

U.S. officials have previously said they feared China may respond to the ruling by declaring an air defence identification zone in the South China Sea, as it did in the East China Sea in 2013, or by stepping up its building and fortification of artificial islands.

United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon called on all parties to resolve the disputes in a "peaceful and amicable manner through dialogue and in conformity with international law."

China claims most of the energy-rich waters through which about $5 trillion in ship-borne trade passes every year.

Finding for the Philippines on a number of issues, the court said there was no legal basis for China to claim historic rights to resources within its so-called nine-dash line, which covers almost 90 percent of the South China Sea.

None of China's reefs and holdings in the Spratly Islands entitled it to a 200-mile exclusive economic zone, it added.

The judges acknowledged China's refusal to participate, but said they sought to take account of China's position from its statements and diplomatic correspondence.

Taiwan, which maintains that the island it occupies, Itu Aba, is legally the only island among hundreds of reefs, shoals and atolls scattered across the seas, said it did not accept the ruling, which seriously impaired Taiwan's territorial rights in the 3.5 million sq km sea.

Fellow claimant Malaysia said it believed disputes could be resolved by diplomatic and legal processes.

A U.S. official who helps set the administration's Asia policies said that faced with the prospect of continuing Chinese assertiveness, it is important for countries in the region and for the United States to avoid provocative actions and leave the door open for Beijing to pursue peaceful solutions "and avoid making matters worse."

He also said, however, that the United States must honour its defence commitments in the Pacific and reassure the Philippines, Vietnam and China's other neighbours that it would not abandon them or Obama's pledge to devote more resources to Asian security.


Construction of possible radar tower facilities in the Spratly Islands in the disputed South China Sea in this image released on February 23, 2016, shown in a satellite image released by the Asian Maritime Transparency Initiative at Washington's Center for Strategic and International Studies. Mandatory credit CSIS Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative/DigitalGlobe/Handout via Reuters/File Photo

U.S. Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton said Tuesday she welcomes an international tribunal's ruling denying China's claims in the South China Sea, saying the waters were "critical" to the U.S. economy.

"The U.S. has a deep and abiding interest in the South China Sea and to the free flow of commerce - so critical to our economy - that flows through it. It is important that all claimants abide by this ruling and continue to pursue peaceful, multilateral means to resolve disputes among them," Clinton said in a statement provided to Reuters.

Clinton, a former secretary of state during President Barack Obama's first term, was involved in the administration's pivot to Asia.

Related news:

> Hague tribunal overwhelmingly rejects Beijing's South China Sea claims

> China urged to #CHexit from 'South China Sea'

> Taiwan rejects ruling on 'South China Sea' island of Itu Aba

> U.S. urges respect for 'South China Sea' ruling

go to top